Liar in the uniform | WHAT REALLY HAPPENED

Liar in the uniform

This guy was a liar. He didn't qualify to be a POW because of the nature of his operation.

Commando in the United States Navy, who had been captured by the German Gestapo on the night of November 30, 1944, along with three Austrian partisans, after completing a mission behind enemy lines. Lt. Taylor had been a prisoner at Mauthausen for only a short time, since April 1, 1945. He had been brought to Mauthausen from a prison in Vienna when the city was evacuated because Soviet troops were near.

Lt. Jack Taylor, US Navy commando, after his liberation

The photograph above shows Lt. Jack H. Taylor, taken shortly after his liberation from Mauthausen. He testified in court that he had weighed only 112 pounds when he was liberated. In the photo, he appears to have regained the weight he lost during his imprisonment. On the jacket that he wore in the camp, Lt. Taylor was required to wear a red triangle, pointing downward, which meant that he was classified as a non-German political prisoner, not an American POW. Because of his work in supplying arms and ammunition to "Marshall Tito and other resistance forces," Lt. Taylor was an illegal combatant according to the Geneva Convention of 1929, and as such, he was not treated as a Prisoner of War by the Germans.

The following quote is from Lt. Jack H. Taylor's Citation for the Navy Cross:

For extraordinary heroism in connection with military operations against an armed enemy of the United States; as chief of the Maritime Unit, Office of Strategic Services Detachment, United States Armed Forces, in the Middle East, from September 1943 to March 1944, Lieutenant Jack Taylor, USNR, personally commanded fourteen separate sorties to the Greek and Balkan enemy-occupied coasts. This activity was carried out despite intense enemy efforts to prevent any kind of coastal traffic whatsoever. Lieutenant Taylor, through clandestine operations, deserving of the highest commendation and careful planning and skillful navigation effected numerous evacuations of intelligence agents, doctors, nurses, and downed airmen. Tons of arms, ammunition, explosives, and other military supplies were delivered to Marshal Tito and other resistance forces through the efforts of Lieutenant Taylor. For three months, at all times surrounded by enemy forces, and on three occasions forced to flee from enemy searching parties, Lieutenant Taylor and his intelligence team operated in Central Albania and transmitted by clandestine radio important information regarding enemy troop movements, supply dumps, coastal fortifications, anti-aircraft installations and other military intelligence of great value to the Allied forces. Parachuting into enemy territory on the night of 13 October 1944, with a team of three Austrian deserter-volunteers, he had personally trained and briefed, he began a secret intelligence mission to Austria. Handicapped from the very start by failure of their plane to drop radio equipment, living in constant danger of capture, and the physical and mental strain on his men, the courage and energy of Lieutenant Taylor prevailed and throughout the remainder of October and November, the mission collected target intelligence of the highest value to the Allies. On 30 November, the eve of their departure for Italy, the party was captured by the Gestapo. Through four months of imprisonment in Vienna and one month in Mauthausen prison camp, he was subjected to the customary interrogation methods of the Gestapo. During his capture, Lieutenant Taylor injured his left arm seriously. With this handicap and also being forced to exist on starvation rations and work at hard labor, he resisted all attempts to force him to divulge security .... the brilliant results of his operations have been an essential aid to the victory of Allied Arms.

Only hours after the liberation of the Mauthausen camp, Lt. Col. George C. Stevens, the famed Hollywood director, arrived to shoot some footage of Lt. Taylor for his film entitled "Nazi Concentration Camps," which was shown at the Nuremberg International Military Tribunal on November 29, 1945. Lt. Taylor was a former dentist from California and he started off by saying that this was the first time he had ever been in a movie.

The photo below shows Lt. Jack H. Taylor on the witness stand at Dachau, looking much the same as he did in the photo taken after he was liberated from Mauthausen.

Lt. Jack Taylor on the witness stand during the Mauthausen case

Prior to the proceedings at Dachau in the Mauthausen case, Lt. Jack Taylor had given the following testimony at the Nuremberg International Military Tribunal:

"In October '44, I was the first Allied officer to drop onto Austria. I was captured December 1st, by the Gestapo, severely beaten, ah, even though I was in uniform, severely beaten, and, and, considered as a non-prisoner of war. I was taken to Vienna prison where I was held for four months. When the Russians neared Vienna, I was taken to this Mauthausen concentration lager [camp], an extermination camp, the worst in Germany, where we have been starving and, and beaten and killed, ah, fortunately, my turn hadn't come. Ah, two American officers at least have been executed here. Here is the insignia of one, a U.S. naval officer, and here is his dog tag. Here is the army officer, executed by gas in this lager [camp]. Ah...there were...

[Question: "How many ways did they execute them?"]

Five or six ways: by gas, by shooting, by beating, that is beating with clubs, ah, by exposure, that is standing out in the snow, naked, for 48 hours and having cold water put on them, thrown on them in the middle of winter, starvation, dogs, and pushing over a hundred-foot cliff."

After only 35 days in the notorious Mauthausen camp, Lt. Taylor knew all about the crimes committed there: torture, hangings, shootings, beatings, and the execution of an unnamed American army officer in the gas chamber.

The photograph below shows the "hundred-foot cliff" where SS soldiers at Mauthausen allegedly forced Dutch Jews to leap from a ledge into the quarry. The narrow ledge is in the center of the photo, a short distance from the top of the quarry.

The "parachute jump" where Dutch prisoners were forced to jump

Lt. Taylor was the first witness for the prosecution in the Mauthausen case, which was brought before an American Military Tribunal at Dachau. By now, he was an experienced prosecution witness and he elaborated on his Nuremberg testimony. When asked by prosecutor Lt. Col. William Denson, on direct examination, how many different forms of killing that he had come in contact with in Mauthausen, Lt. Taylor testified as follows:

Gassing, hanging, shooting, beating. There was one particular group of Dutch Jews who were beaten until they jumped over the cliff into the stone quarry. Some that were not killed on the first fall were taken back up and thrown over to be sure. Then there was exposure. Any new transport coming in was forced to stand out in the open, regardless of the time of the year, practically naked. Other forms of killing included clubbing to death with axes or hammers and so forth, tearing to pieces by dogs specially trained for the purpose, injections into the heart and veins with magnesium chloride or benzene, whippings with a cow-tail to tear the flesh away, mashing in a concrete mixer, forcing them to drink a great quantity of water and jumping on the stomach while the prisoner was lying on his back, freezing half-naked in subzero temperatures, buried alive, red-hot poker down the throat. I remember a very prominent Czech general who was held down in the shower room and had a hose forced down his throat. He drowned that way.

Of course, Lt. Taylor had never seen anyone carried back up to the top of a cliff and thrown off a second time, nor had he ever seen anyone mashed in a concrete mixer, nor killed with a red-hot poker shoved down his throat. These were stories that he had heard from the other prisoners. This kind of hearsay testimony was common in all the Dachau proceedings. The purpose of reiterating these stories in sworn testimony on the witness stand was to get these atrocities entered into the record, so that these alleged crimes would go down in history for future generations to read as the gospel truth.

Lt. Taylor may have been confused about the nationality of the general since the Czechoslovakian Army did not fight when Germany invaded. There were similar stories about a Russian general, Lt. Gen. Dmitry Mikhailovich Karbyshev, who was either drowned in the shower or forced to stand outside in freezing weather while water was poured over him on some unknown date in February 1945. The stories about dying from exposure were based on the fact that the prisoners had to take a shower and then stand naked outside while their clothes and barracks were disinfected in an effort to prevent typhus which is spread by body lice.

Under cross examination, the defense attorney established that Lt. Taylor had only seen "maybe five or six" of the 61 accused men while he was at Mauthausen, and that Lt. Taylor could not say for certain whether any of the accused had committed any of these alleged atrocities while he was at Mauthausen. That didn't matter since, under the common design charge, anyone who was a member of the camp staff where any crime was committed was guilty of that crime, even if he was not on the staff at the time of the crime. Hearsay evidence was allowed by the tribunal, so it didn't matter if Lt. Taylor had personally seen any of these alleged atrocities committed. It was enough that he had heard these stories from other inmates, who were not present in the courtroom and thus could not be cross-examined.

Lt. Taylor testified in the trial that he had been scheduled to die in the Mauthausen gas chamber on May 6, 1945, but he was miraculously saved when American troops arrived the day before his planned execution. Lt. Taylor was the only American ever to testify for the prosecution in the Dachau trials and his testimony was considered to be more credible than that of the other former prisoners who might have been seeking revenge, more than justice.

In his direct testimony, Lt. Taylor was asked by prosecutor Lt. Col. William Denson to describe the gas chamber. As quoted by Joshua M. Greene in "Justice at Dachau," Lt. Taylor testified as follows:

Yes, sir. It was rigged up like a shower room with shower nozzles in the ceiling. New prisoners thought they were going in to have their bath. They were stripped and put in this room naked. Then gas came out of the shower nozzles.

The photo below, taken in May 2003, shows one of the shower nozzles, and water pipes coming through the wall into the Mauthausen gas chamber. The gas chamber was cleverly disguised as a real shower room with real water pipes, real shower heads and real floor drains. However, Lt. Taylor was wrong about the gas coming through the shower heads. The gas was in the form of pellets, about the size of peas, which were usually heated so that the poisonous gas fumes would be released faster.

Shower head and water pipes in Mauthausen gas chamber

According to the testimony of another Mauthausen prisoner, the poison gas flowed through a tube placed low on the wall of the shower room. In his book entitled "The 186 Steps," Christian Bernadac quoted the testimony of Werner Reinsdorf, a prisoner who came to Mauthausen in 1941 and was assigned Prison Number 535 which had previously been assigned to another man who died. Reinsdorf "took part in the construction of the gas chamber," according to Bernadac.

The following quote from Bernadac's book is the words of Werner Reinsdorf:

There was a tube that led into the gas chamber, eighty centimeters above the floor, with its opening turned toward the wall so as to escape notice. The gas flowed through this tube...I, myself, saw Jews being led to the gas chamber....

According to stories told by former inmates at Mauthausen, there was a small metal box, near the floor on the other side of one of the shower room walls. An open can of Zyklon-B gas pellets was put into this box, along with a hot brick which heated the pellets to the proper temperature so that prussic acid could be released. An enameled tube, through which the gas flowed, led from the box into the shower room. Unknown to Lt. Taylor, who expected to be gassed on May 6, 1945, Commandant Franz Ziereis had allegedly removed the box and the tube just before he escaped from the camp on the night of May 2, 1945. The tile in the shower room was replaced, and the wall, where the box had been located, was so skillfully repaired that no evidence of how the gas entered the room can be seen today.

The photograph below shows a glass case in the Museum at Mauthausen in which an open can of Zyklon-B pellets is displayed. The Museum displays are in the basement of the former hospital building where the gas chamber is located. This type of poison gas was also used in all the concentration camps to disinfect the clothing by killing the body lice which spreads typhus.

Zyklon-B pellets on display at the Mauthausen museum

After Lt. Jack Taylor arrived at the Mauthausen camp on April 1, 1945, he was put to work "setting tile in the new crematorium," according to his trial testimony. He testified that the camp administrators "were very anxious to have it completed because all the bodies from hanging and beating had to be cremated to destroy the evidence." Lt. Taylor testified that "We knew that the only thing that kept the number of violent deaths down was the fact that the crematorium couldn't take care of any more. And we knew that as soon as we finished, the rate would accelerate tremendously because it was a more efficient oven." He stated that "the regular procedure for the gas chamber was twice a day, one hundred and twenty at a time. I would say that the new crematorium increased the facilities to two hundred and fifty a day."

According to Lt. Taylor's testimony, the new crematorium was first used on Sunday, April 10, 1945. The photograph below, taken in May 2003, shows the new crematorium, which is in the same building as the gas chamber. The flooring in front of the ovens is glazed brick, the same as that used for the floor of the gas chambers at both Mauthausen and Dachau. There is also what looks like floor tile, next to the bricks.

New Crematorium at Mauthausen concentration camp

In his direct testimony for the prosecution, Lt. Taylor described the burning of corpses on the first day that the new crematorium was put to use:

Three hundred and sixty-seven prisoners, including forty women, arrived from Czechoslovakia. They had been marched overland, straight through the gate to the crematorium. This particular group had so much more fat - so much more fat, than ordinary prisoners that the flames from the crematorium were going straight out the top of the smokestack. Ordinarily it was a pale brown smoke, heavy with the smell of burnt hair, and it wafted over the camp. It seemed to go up, then settle down. As hungry as we were, we had a hard time eating sometimes."

The photo below shows the smoke stack for the underground crematorium at Mauthausen. The street in the foreground is the main camp road. On the left in the photo is the gate into the Quarantine camp where incoming prisoners were held for two weeks in order to prevent the spread of disease. There was a typhus epidemic at Mauthausen and 400 prisoners were dying each day, but according to Lt. Taylor's testimony, 367 prisoners were marched from Czechoslovakia to Mauthausen during the epidemic, and instead of being taken to the Quarantine camp, they were immediately taken to the crematorium to be killed and then burned in the new oven. The stairs down to the crematorium are next to the green building, and directly across from the Quarantine camp.

Smoke stack for underground cremation ovens at Mauthausen

Gas Chamber Testimony
Confessions of the Accused
Prosecution Witnesses
Back to the start of Mauthausen Trial
The Case against August Eigruber
The Defense Case
Trial of Spanish Kapos
Franz Kofler Trial
Back to Dachau Trials
Back to Mauthausen index

This page was last updated on July 14, 2009